Three people have asked for the same Friday off in December. The employee experience team wants to plan the team party and needs to confirm a budget. Meanwhile, you’re figuring out how to share year-end bonuses along with normal payroll. These requests all tend to land in the same few weeks, when you have the least time to research any of them. The good news? The holidays are predictable. They come around every year. If you haven’t established these processes before, you can set simple rules once and ensure everyone on the team gets the answers they need. Some structure up front keeps the season fun for your team and manageable for you. This post covers three common holiday decisions: how to handle time-off requests when everyone wants the same time, how to host a celebration that brings your team together, and what payroll needs to account for with bonuses, gifts, and extra time off. How Do You Balance Holiday Time-Off Requests and Business Needs? Even if everyone wants the same days off, the business still needs to open its doors, answer the phones, and serve customers. Saying yes to every PTO request isn’t always feasible at the holidays. The goal becomes to make fair decisions in a transparent manner. Start with the rules, not the requests. Fairness is easier to defend when the method was set before anyone asked. Here’s what to settle before December: A deadline for holiday PTO requests: Pick a date for peak holiday weeks so you see all the requests at once instead of one at a time. Know how conflicts will be resolved: Common approaches include first come, first served, rotating priority from year to year, or seniority. Establish minimum coverage by role: Decide how many people each team needs on any given day. Then the conversation is about coverage, not about whose reason is better. When you have to say no, offer those affected employees at least one alternative. Flexible hours, a partial day, an early start to make up the time, or a different day that week could be plausible solutions. A few guardrails apply along the way. In New York, a paid, covered sick leave request isn’t something you can deny. Whether unused PTO carries over or gets paid out at year-end depends on what your written policy says, so make sure it says something. And if you close the office for a day or two, salaried employees who are exempt from overtime still receive their regular salary. Time-off rules belong in your handbook, where everyone can find them. READ MORE: Build Your First Employee Handbook That Works How Do You Host a Celebration That Builds Culture? A good holiday celebration feels different than your standard monthly staff meeting. It gives your team a shared experience by celebrating each other and celebrating everything you’ve accomplished together. Crafting an event that excites employees and works for the business comes down to a few choices: Will you hold it during work hours? A team lunch or an afternoon gathering supports those employees who would otherwise have to find childcare or give up an evening. Some teams might enjoy a special night out together. Ask your team for input during the planning process where it makes sense to do so. Make attendance optional, or pay for it. If employees are required or expected to attend, the time can count as hours worked for non-exempt employees, including overtime. Holding the event during the regular workday is the simplest fix. Plan for everyone. Don’t center the whole event on one tradition, and think about food and drink options for different dietary needs. An “end-of-year celebration” invites everyone in. Set the tone before the toast. If alcohol will be served, remind people that workplace conduct expectations still apply, limit the drinks, and make sure everyone has a safe ride home. Injuries and incidents at company-sponsored events can lead to workers’ compensation claims and potential harassment complaints. Beyond the logistics, what matters is what you do with the time together. Use it to recognize specific contributions from the year: an impact moment serving a customer, a project that a team delivered and exceeded expectations, a teammate who stepped up. A party that celebrates real accomplishments does more for culture than any decoration. And if you want that appreciation to carry past January, build it into how your team works every day. READ MORE: How to Make Every Day Feel Like Employee Appreciation Day READ MORE: Do’s and Don’ts for Supporting Employees During the Holiday Season What Does Payroll Need to Account for with Bonuses, Gifts, and Extra Time Off? Depending on the exact nature of a holiday gift to employees, it can be considered taxable pay that needs to run through payroll. Your approach should account for a few different situations. Cash gifts are considered taxable wages no matter how small the amount. This also includes things like gift cards that function as cash gifts. This should go through payroll, not out of petty cash or onto a company card. Small physical gifts, like giving employees a turkey or ham at the holidays, are considered de minimis items and generally are not taxed. The key determinants here are whether these gifts are occasional, and whether they are low-value. Holiday bonuses are taxed as supplemental wages, so withholding can look different from a regular paycheck. Your payroll team can walk you through the options. There’s also a question for hourly, overtime-eligible employees: was the bonus promised, or tied to attendance, productivity, or performance? If so, it generally should be included when calculating their overtime pay for the period it covers. A true discretionary bonus, where you choose the amount and timing with no prior promise, typically doesn’t. Know which kind you’re giving before you announce it. Closing early on Christmas Eve or giving an extra day off is a great gift. Decide in writing whether it’s paid. Hourly employees are paid only for hours worked unless you choose otherwise, and salaried employees who are overtime-exempt receive their regular pay when you close for less than a week. If you do pay hourly staff for the time, remember this: hours not worked don’t count toward the 40-hour overtime threshold per FLSA rules, and we recommend outlining this in your company handbook. However the holiday season plays out, a few habits keep payroll clean. Decide on bonuses and gifts before your last payroll of the year. They’re generally taxed in the year the employee receives them. Tell your payroll team the same day you announce anything, so it’s coded correctly before the cutoff. Put the details in writing, including whether a gift is one-time. That keeps a generous gesture from becoming an expectation. ‘Tis the Season for a New HR Partner The holiday season is easier when you’ve answered these questions before they come up. They’re easier still with a partner who has helped businesses through them year after year. Employer Services Corporation has helped businesses in Western New York and beyond manage the people side of their work. As a Professional Employer Organization (PEO), ESC provides the talent and technology needed to manage their people and run their processes smoothly. Whether you want a straight conversation about getting your holiday plans in place before the busy season, or you want to get ahead of anything related to HR in the new year, contact our team today.